Monday, 23 November 2009

Doctor Who update

Alright four things regards to Doctor who this last week or so so let's look at them.

Waters of Mars
Waters of Mars was fantastic, the Doctors continuous insistence that he can't do anything while bowie base one (heh) is destroyed by the Waters of Mars. It really dealt with the repercussions of time travel and responsibilities of those with that technology. It's just a shame everyone made the wrong choice. Yet again the humans involved are too narrow minded to see the big picture and end up fearing the Doctor. It's interesting to see, but in the end you just want to reach into the TV and slap some sense into the fools.
I'm reminded of the episode Family of Blood, at the end the nurse makes two points. They are very thoughtful, but if you think about it the answers, while heartless, make sense. The first point she raises is that the Doctor chose to hide rather than face the Family. We, the viewer, knows that it was out of kindness and compassion for his enemies. Not fear. She then asks if the Doctor hadn't chosen to land there would the people have died.
These are two themes from the Tenth Doctor. Even through his kindness people die. He truly is a harbinger of death and when he choses to fight back there is nothing he will not do. The second theme is this fear that people have of him, even though he is doing the right thing for everyone. It makes this version a tragic hero, even more so with his time coming to an end.
He loses everyone and everything because he does what is best for them, no matter the cost. That's why they fear him, they fear his sense of self sacrifice.
I think I will really miss this take on him.

Speaking of The End of Time
The two part end to Tennent's time as the Doctor promises to be a real storm. There is nothing he won't do, this time on his own has really effected him recently. Without someone to hold him back this Champion of Time is on the warpath. Okay here is my predictions for the story so spoilers:-

1:- Donna is going to be a lot more important than we first thought. I don't think she's going to just be a cameo.

2:- The Master. We know he is back, but I think it was Donna that picked up the ring! After all she was trying to catch up with the Doctor. Look at that hand again.

3:- The Ood. We know, from an exclusive clip during Children in Need, that they are developing too fast. Building vast cities in a very short time. Something is propelling them. Some unseen influence that is sensitive to time and I think it's friendly. Or at least close to. This is a long shot but I think the Matrix (a repository of knowledge of the Auto... sorry Time Lords since the beginning of time) survived the destruction of Gallifray and found it's way to the Ood. It might even have created them as it's own custodians. It's even possible that the whole race was, from the beginning, a Chameleon Arch construct to hide the Time Lords while their planet blew up.

4:- Back to The Master. This is different to point two so I separated it. This is about the moment he flickers in and out of reality in the trailer. Some people say that it's like a dalek gun, but it's not. My opinion is that the Master doesn't exist yet, but in fine Bill and Ted style he will exist, just as so as he gets around to it. In plain English he recreates himself with a paradox, by going back in time but if he doesn't recreate himself he won't exist. It's a paradox on this scale that is going to destroy two thirds of the universe and decimate time. Hence the plot of the two part-er.

Those are my four predictions for The End of Time. So by Christmas we'll know if I was close, no where near, or somewhere in between. At least they're out there

Alright third part. Sarah Jane Adventures series three
An uneven series that neither advanced the story from last season or degraded. It felt exactly the same with good stories and unremarkable ones. The season end was, while remarkably predictable and bland, but after the Doctors appearance everything would be. Still everyone involved put in a solid performance and did a fantastic job.

The highlight was undoubtedly the arrival of the Doctor. Coming across in his story like a whirlwind, but he felt oddly hampered. As if he had one hand tied behind his back. This was to give the SJA crew a chance to shine, but still you feel that if the solution was that simple the Doctor had the perfect opportunity not five minuets earlier .

The champion of this series was Clyde. Displaying a vast library of talents under his court jester personality, from artistic skills that won a national award to master chef style cooking. Daniel Anthony (the actor) shows he's got a fantastic range and has the ability, just like Tommy Knight (Luke), to make a living out of his performance. I would have preferred Rani to have had more to do, perhaps been the closet painter instead of Clyde. Growing from the simple Maria replacement she was last season, unfortunately that was not to be.

The worst part was undoubtedly the Mona Lisa's Revenge. Clyde's artistic talent (while I like the development) came out of nowhere at the beginning of the episode and you get the feeling it will never come up again. I'm struggling to think of a way to describe just how completely off the mark they got Mona Lisa. Imagine it like comparing the American Godzilla to the Japanese Classic version. As a matter of fact it didn't need to be the most famous painting in the world, without changing the script in the slightest you could have done it about any painting.

Just the drive my knife in a little deeper, for a show so buried in Doctor who mythology it missed the previous adventure involving the Mona Lisa. Namely that the only copy that survives has "This is a fake" written underneath the paint in felt tip (see City of Death).

So all in all SJA has it's flaws, but is still an enjoyable and entertaining show.

Fourth and final article to address. Dreamland
We're only half way though this animated episode but it really is looking good. A couple of years ago they did an animated episode called the Infinite Quest, it was a good addition to the series and took the story away from earth for a change. This is in the same vain and just like that shouldn't be dismissed just because it's animated.

Dreamland is set in 1950's America and makes use of all the Saucer men, grey aliens, MIB's and assorted other nonsense from that time. As you might expect it does the job with a flair and style. Tennent pushes his voice acting to almost unexplored levels of ham, mostly because the animation is so stiff. None of the fluid movements and subtle (or not) actions he's usually able to bring to the role.

Like Waters of Mars Anything I do say would be full of spoilers and while I'll do that out of spite with something I detest Dreamland is far too good. Even with flaws it's fun, clever, and well engineered.

Well that's it. More updates as they come!

No comments:

Post a Comment